Fishing... Discerning...


For sermon videos these days, CLICK HERE

Easter 3C 


In the name of God, who meets us with surprising blessings when we follow our call.  Amen.

 

As a child, I always had a bit of a way with words.  It’s no surprise that the vocation God revealed to me ended up having a lot to do with words – and the ways that these words can be opened up in front of us to help us know and experience God.

 

My parents will be here visiting in a couple of weeks, and I’m sure they’d tell you – that “way with words” that I had could land in different ways at different times.  Sometimes I might articulate some observation that seemed to reveal unearned and early wisdom.  Sometimes I could be really funny.  But, of course, it wasn’t all great…

 

My favorite way of crafting words was – and sometimes still is – sarcasm…  Shade…  Being a smart aleck.  As a child, my parents would find it intermittently amusing and infuriating – depending on the context, and how far I’d push it.  And I’m sure Michael feels the same – sometimes he’s laughing with me, sometimes, very not…

 

One of my smart alecky observations as a child, that I still think of sometimes, was when something was lost and I’d run to my mom for help finding it.  She’d invariably list off some expected places where the lost thing might be.  Yes, I’d looked there.  After a while she’d give up and say, “It’ll be in the last place you look.”

 

Frustrated, I’d say, “Well, yeah.  Why would I keep looking if I’d already found it?”

 

In all of our readings today, the message is simple and consistent: God’s blessings flow from where we’d least expect them – in the very last places we’d think to look.


For the disciples it was literal.  The freshness and the grief of the crucifixion was still very real.  They knew of the Resurrection, but they still didn’t know what that meant for them in their lives.  And there comes a point in every experience of grief, when you’ve just got to start trying to move on with your life in your new context.  Even if it doesn’t make sense, you’ve got to try to cling to whatever you can find that might make sense.

 

For Simon Peter it was fishing.  The world wasn’t making much sense, and he was feeling profoundly vulnerable – physically, politically, spiritually.  So, he needed to cling to something that would make sense – something where he felt like he knew what was going on – if only for a moment.  So, he said to his friends, “I’m going fishing.”  Other disciples joined him, and they went out on the water, working all night, and all for nothing.  They hadn’t caught anything.

 

But then Jesus came, and he said, look where you hadn’t thought to look before: and suddenly the blessings – in this story in the form of fish – couldn’t be contained.  It took all the men to pull them in and it strained the limits of the nets.  All because they decided to follow Christ and look somewhere new – somewhere they wouldn’t have expected.

 

You know, whenever a priest begins a new ministry in a new setting, one of the questions that gets asked of us again and again is: how did it come to be?  And in our situation, where a call to ministry led to such a big trans-regional move, and picking up a whole family’s worth of lives and setting them down in another place – the questions are even stronger.

 

So, settle in, children, it’s story time.

 

The call process for priestly ministry is so very different from just about any other kind of job transition process.  Because very little of it is about the “job” part of ministry.  Of course there’s some of that, but that’s not the biggest part.  When it’s done faithfully, it is a deeply prayerful process.  And, for me at least, that doesn’t just mean going to God with questions or petitions – not even just with silence, which I believe to be one of the holiest forms of prayer.

 

Discernment prayer is about deep, vulnerable honesty.  It means sometimes getting pissed off at God.  Sometimes falling down in exasperated agony.  Sometimes crying – literal tears – at how lost we feel.  And then, through all of that, finding yourself newly opened to the Holy Spirit of Wisdom, and the ways that she pulls us into places and situations we never could have imagined on our own.  In discernment, God takes our biggest dreams and laughs out loud at how we’ve limited ourselves – at how small we’ve let ourselves become.  In discernment, God pulls us through barriers we didn’t even know where there – much less that we might dare to cross them.

 

So that’s how our journey together started – through years of me feeling the Holy Spirit needling me into thinking that God must have something in store for me – and me prayerfully, painfully learning how to open myself to that unknown horizon.

 

In those years, I read about literally hundreds of churches and other ministry settings.  Only very rarely did something pique my interest enough to have me even consider entering into formal discernment for the position.

 

A couple of years ago, Michael and I were passing through Toledo on a vacation, and we stopped by to stay for a couple of days to visit our friend Andrea and her family.  I was in the very deep end of discernment at that point and struggling to hold myself up.  By that point I knew something was coming and I was trying to help God usher it into the world however I could.

 

So, one night Andrea and Michael and I were talking about it – this vocational cauldron I was swimming in.  I had sort of imagined for myself a few different ways that I might meet this calling that was bubbling so loudly around me.  We talked through the various options I had in my mind and ranked them in terms of the order I thought best suited my call.  Option A, option B, option C…  Where we left the conversation that night, was that whatever happened, there were options – any one of which, I believed, would lead me to that vocational growth I was craving.  Now mind you, Trinity, Toledo was none of those options.  If I’d counted out to option Q, this place never would have been a thought in my mind.  I’d never even heard of it.

 

And then, over the course of the next several months, those options that I could imagine started to fall apart.  I was devastated.  I believed to the point of deep soul-knowing that God was calling me to something more, but it just wasn’t happening.  I had a lot of those ugly prayers with God that people often think you shouldn’t have.  I questioned my vocation, entirely.

 

Eventually, in the same way that Jesus told the disciples to drop the net into different waters – unplanned and unexpected waters, I found Trinity.  In what was to me, an unplanned and unexpected place.  And in the same way that the disciples started pulling in their nets and noticing abundance and blessings that they couldn’t have imagined, I started pulling in my net here, and the more I invited Michael into the process to pull along with me, we both found that same sort of abundance and blessing such as we never could have imagined on our own, coming into view.  The nets were full and still coming.

 

The story of Saul – who we’d later come to know as Paul – is of the same sort.  He was a man who assumed he was following God’s call.  It was an understanding of God’s call that the leaders of his community told him was an authentic call.  He was a persecutor of Christians.  And not even with a passive hate.  He sought out those early Christians.  He hunted them.  And his only goal was to bring them before the leaders in Jerusalem to make them pay.  He was ruthless.

 

That’s the context of Saul’s encounter with Christ.  He was out on a mission to hunt down the followers of Christ.  And then, to his great surprise, he found Christ instead.  He would be blinded by the insight, and then, in three days, see the world in a whole new way – his own resurrection experience of personal growth.

 

The long and short of it is this: like the disciples clinging to their fishing in a world where nothing else made sense; like Saul, thinking the world made perfect sense and that he’d go on forever just as he was; just like them, we make our plans.  It’s good to make plans.  Ask the members of the staff here at Trinity, I love planning.  But even after we’ve made our plans, we meet God in the surprises.  We meet God in the improvisation that dances around our plans; and sometimes even in the cacophony that derails our plans entirely.

 

And my goodness, the ways that meeting God can disrupt and derail and remap our plans can be a pain in the neck.  It can mess us up.  Saul’s plans certainly got messed up.  And the fishing disciples wanted to catch fish, but pulling in those overloaded nets that nearly broke and nearly sank the boat – that wasn’t their plan.  That was a lot of work.

 

People sometimes think that if something is a part of God’s plan, then it must be affirmed with simplicity and ease.  If God wanted it, it wouldn’t be so hard.  The thing is, that’s just almost never true.  God’s call might be affirmed by feeling natural and sometimes even by feeling good, but it’s almost never easy.

 

The Holy Spirit almost never pulls us in a straight line.  She pulls us through twists and turns and hills and valleys.  Discernment is hard.  Being called by God is hard.

 

But avoiding God’s call in our lives is harder.  Walking a lonely road and choosing to live your life in a way that contradicts the love and the grace and the hopefulness that was embodied in Jesus’ way is harder.  It’s blinding.

 

But through the discernment, and through the calling there are incomprehensible blessings.  Blessings so abundant and so vast that God laughs when we even try to imagine them.  So abundant and so vast that they could only ever be seen through the spiritual gift of surprise.

 

The unsuccessful net teaches us; and the blinding walk teaches us; and most of all the empty tomb teaches us that God works through surprise.  God works through wonder and curiosity.  And the real surprise – the real wonder and curiosity of it all: God works through us.  In our fear, in our anger, in our misunderstanding, in our dreaming too small: surprise!  God works through us.  God blesses us and keeps blessing us.  And not just for ourselves, but so that we can be the blessings the world needs.

 

That’s our charge: receive the blessing.  But most importantly, be the blessing.  Amen.

Comments